Sunday, November 20, 2005

# 111: Response to Comments

I am writing this post in response to comments I received from a relative of mine who is an extremely intelligent person with an excellent memory. About two months ago, he asked me if intelligent design belonged in the biology class. I gave him a hard copy of post #109, "Creation, Evolution, and Intelligent Design," because he is a physical chemist and I wanted to get some scientific input on the subject of discussion. I am not certain what his status is concerning his belief in God, and what effect God has on his life. But I do know that he believes in most, if not all, fields of science. I will quote only the excerpts in #109, relative to his comments. If you desire to know what the context of my responses is, click on post #109.

1) On his first comment, I could understand why he commented: because I didn’t make myself clear enough. Therefore, I clarified this next excerpt: “I don’t mean to actually delete those early chapters, but for informed Christians to, at least in their mind, realize the writer’s limited knowledge and improvise creation’s time frame as being much longer than six 24-hour earth days.” This was his comment: “Bad example. Moses did understand what a day was. God could have said millions of years.” The changes I made were to put an apostrophe in the word “writer’s,” move a comma in back of “improvise,” and change the pronoun “the” to “creation’s.”

2) “And yet, with all those mistakes, the Bible is by all means the best source of information in existence that relays to humanity why God exists and what God and life are all about.” His comment was, “How do you know this?” My response is this: The proof is in the pudding. I have had plenty of years to try many lifestyles to find lasting meaning in my life. In the end, every one of them failed. What the Bible teaches, if practiced without reservation, fulfills one’s most intrinsic needs. And isn’t that what we are all seeking?

3) “And I truly believe that holy book was inspired by God; He had it written by fallible men in such a way, so that men/women could understand, for the limited knowledge they had at the time.” His comment was: “Where’s the latest version? Did God retire?” My answer is this: To my knowledge, the New International Version Bible is still used as the best source for accuracy. And then I think he inserted a little bit of jest about God retiring.

4) “Therefore, the winner is the one who has the most plausible answer, and for that reason, is the closest to possibly having the correct answer.” His comment was this: “This is absurd. Apply it to planetary motion, and physics would not exist.” My response is this: Physics, evolution and natural selection have not been able to answer the question of how the information encoded in DNA molecules formed on its own in the first living organism. And until they have the answer to that question, intelligent design is the best answer. If it violates the laws of physics, so be it. Just remember that believing in the existence of God violates physics. Therefore, the laws of physics break down when God enters the picture. Could that be why many brilliant scientists don’t believe in God?

5) “Biology and evolution argue that intelligent design is attempting to sneak God into the biology class and the school room through the back door. That must never be allowed.” This was his comment: “Why do you need to know everything?” I will respond to that question with a question: Does God desire for us to remain ignorant on matters that will better our lives, especially for inquisitive people like myself? If there is something to be known which will better our lives, I desire to know it. Is that what you mean by the word “everything”?

6) “Unanswered questions.” This was his comment: “All possibilities are infinite, including mice made the world. Again, why can’t we just accept there are things we don’t know?” My response is this: There are at least, if not only, two excellent questions in the world: questions that have not yet been asked, and questions that have no apparent answers.

7) “Now the question arises, how could this motor have arisen from a population of bacteria without tails, through natural selection?” His comment was this: His argument. “After-X-years of bacterial evolution on day -Y- of history, God added a flagellin to X bacteria.” This is my response: As mentioned previously, evolution, which implies natural selection, could not have functioned without information; where did that genetic information in the first bacterium come from?

8) “Again, there is no natural system that can produce information.” His comment was this: “Bacteria already had information available and were mutating and swapping information.” This is my response: Information needs intelligence/a mind to come into existence. Where did that information which the “bacteria already had” come from? Sounds like we are going around and around.

9) “If the universe was the result of a gigantic explosion, it was mostly likely an intelligent metaphysical force (which I call God) that created that bit of physical matter out of thin air, so to speak. That makes more sense than a random unknown force or energy.” His comment was this: “And if not? If you’re wrong? Let's say God did start everything. Why should we call point G the beginning when it was really A?” This is my response: It won’t be the first time I have been wrong. In the second part, I have no answer because I don’t understand the logic to the question.

Since post #109 is so controversial, feel free to send in your comments and criticism.


Continued… He also gave me a comment on post #108, “Where is Your Heart?” In the second-to-last paragraph: “And lastly, love God with all your might and love for the needy.” His comment was: “Firstly! Why? Would God be happier if you spent your money on starving children or on this blog? Do you care more about the needy or this blog?” This is my response: That is a soul-searching question. I must attempt for a balance. But even more importantly, which will bring God the greatest glory, and which will make Him known as He desires to be known? That would be my primary motive, while not neglecting the needy or children. But one thing to remember is that the secular world does help the needy, and at the same time God receives no glory for that charity. Therefore, when I help those in need, I must make certain the gifts go toward wholesome things and not toward alcohol, tobacco, and drugs. I live in a panhandler district, and am approached quite often by beggars. To just give my money to them is foolish and possibly harmful. I always ask them what the money is for. If they say food or clothing, I will go with them and buy what is needed. As for helping starving children and giving God the glory, I have not been able to participate in that type of giving. Just to give to a charitable organization, hoping children are helped, I, at this time, will not participate. And at the same time, my heart actually goes out with many tears to these misfortunate children that I see on TV.


JC said...

I understand where you are coming from.

Anonymous said...

FDA Approved Immunity in Michigan
For this price we give you fast and descrete shipping

Anonymous said...

Sildenafil citrate, sold under the name Viagra is the first of a new group of medication which allows adequate sexual stimulation, relaxes the blood vessels of the penis and helps erection..More info

Sex-preteen, xxx fantacy, babis porno, lolita-japanese, young virgin,

Finding a hot couple for swapping was easy.

Faint free sex chat websites lines showed on both of their buttocks where they had been playing earlier.

How does a couple revive a fizzling sex life? One sure fire way is.

of male gay naked gays of delhi free long gay porn samples gay incest

Free gay fetish porn pictures sites by a complete smut pervert just for you.

war gay sex sex picture in the sex matter, sex anyway? ...

Honey said Ray would have been very upset with her girls home alone webcam she didn't accept the car as a gift.

Lesbian sex porn free black lesbian having sex her .

porno videos sex porno free gallery mature wmv porno free daily trailers ...

Anonymous said...

Omnivore News Portal is powered by Dew-NewPHPLinks, a powerful link exchange and web
buy cheap VIAGRA online


best online casinos
green birkenstock clogs

6 bench grinder heavy duty bench grinder


Anonymous said...

The world's leading iPod resource for news, reviews, forums, tips, tutorials
BUY LOW-COST LEVITRA ONLINE - An incredible online casino experience offering blackjack, roulette, craps, slots, and video poker. Deposit now and get up to $555 FREE!

Looking for bmw? Visit the top recommended sites for bmw and find exactly what you are looking for quickly. Quality information on bmw is at Informed Auto

absorption of bovine colostrum in humans

articles for against bovine colostrum
bovine colostrum and autoimmune

Anonymous said...

Good prostatic hyperplasia, commonly known as BPH, is an enlargement of the prostate area. It is more exuberant in older men. As men are becoming more critical far strength issues, they turn to medical treatment as a replacement for BPH. Dutas, a generic appearance of Avodart([URL=]avodart hairloss[/URL] [URL=]avodart anxiety[/URL] [URL=]avodart and eye surgery[/URL] [URL=]avodart directions[/URL] [URL=]shedding duration on avodart[/URL] ), has been proven as an functional treatment of BPH. BPH and its symptoms that adversely assume the eminence of lifestyle can be treated successfully at near Dutas. The primary hint of BPH is the frequency of basic to urinate. This occurs usually at night but then progresses to the necessary to urine frequently throughout the day. BPH sufferers subsequently tell of a reduction in strength in urine stream. Discomfort accompanies this reduction. A medical doctor should direct testing to terminate if BPH is the genesis of the symptoms. The effectiveness of Dutas is start in the chemical compound Dutasteride. This efficacious ingredient is an alpha-reductase 5 inhibitor which impedes the conversion of testosterone into dihydrotestosterone (DHT). DHT is considered a effective species of testosterone. BPH symptoms vanish if ever the conversion is interrupted. Dutas has been organize to be junk in BPH towards many sufferers. Prescriptions finasteride and finasteride has been shown to at best inhibit limerick isoform of alpha redictase 5. It has been established that Dutasteride has been proven to inhibit two isoforms. Dutas manifestly appears to victual the pre-eminent treatment at one's disposal seeking BPH. Dutas make be charmed as directed with some precautions. Erectile dysfunction and decreased sexy libido are the most commonly reported side effects during use of Dutas. Gynecomastia or enlargement of male boob tissue is another accomplishable side effect. Additionally, women who are suggestive or women disappointing to be proper pregnant should not be exposed to Dutas; developing masculine fetuses can be adversely afflicted on these inhibitors. Dutas can be engaged under the aegis the peel so unorthodox care should be exercised notwithstanding expressive women or women unsatisfying to fit pregnant. Another side impression of Dutas is a favourable one. Some men oblige reported curls replenishment while entrancing Dutas. BPH can be treated by way of discussing medications and plausible side effects with a medical professional. Dutas can specify impressive treatment of BPH. A worry-free, brisk life is successfully quality the effort.
[URL=]avodart effectiveness hair loss[/URL]
[URL=]avodart for bph[/URL]
[URL=]avodart flomax prostate[/URL]
[URL=]avodart drug[/URL]

Anonymous said...

Hello very cool web site.

Anonymous said...

Hey very cool blog.

Anonymous said...

Hiya very nice site.

Anonymous said...

Hello very nice website.